What are the challenges of redecking wood decks with composite?

Table of Contents

When it comes to home improvement and deck maintenance, redecking wood decks is a subject that often arises. On the surface, it might appear as a cost-effective solution, but once you delve deeper into the process, you’ll soon realize it’s a path lined with several complexities and challenges.

What is Redecking?

Redecking is the process of removing the old decking boards and replacing them with new ones, essentially giving the deck a fresh surface. This approach relies on the existing structure, specifically the joists and beams underneath, to remain intact and in good condition to support the new boards. It’s often seen as a cost-effective alternative to building a new deck, particularly when the visible parts of the existing deck — the boards themselves — are the only elements showing signs of wear or damage.

Common Misconceptions about Redecking

Redecking wood decks is often seen as a straightforward solution to refreshing an aging outdoor space. However, several misconceptions surround the process, leading homeowners to underestimate the complexities and potential challenges involved.

  • Misconception 1: Redecking is a Simple Process: Many believe that redecking simply involves removing old deck boards and replacing them with new ones. However, the reality is far more complex. The process often uncovers hidden issues in the deck’s substructure, like rotting joists or rusted screws, which require additional repair or replacement.
  • Misconception 2: If the Substructure Looks Good, It Is Good: Appearance can be deceiving. A deck’s substructure may appear sound, but it could be concealing water damage or other forms of deterioration that become evident only after the top boards are removed.
  • Misconception 3: Redecking Always Saves Money: While redecking can be cost-effective in some scenarios, the potential savings can quickly disappear when unexpected problems arise, leading to extra costs.
  • Misconception 4: All Decks are Suitable for Redecking: Not all decks are good candidates for redecking. Decks that are very old, those that have extensive structural issues, or those that were not properly built in the first place may not be suitable for redecking.

The Hidden Challenges of Redecking Wood Decks

Redecking wood decks, though seemingly straightforward, comes with several hidden challenges. In this section, we delve deeper into the potential problems you might encounter during the redecking process.

Underlying Damage

One of the significant challenges with redecking is the risk of unseen damage. Over time, water intrusion and other environmental factors can lead to structural issues that aren’t visible until the top boards are removed. Rotting joists, damp insulation, and mold are among the problems that can suddenly become apparent, leading to additional work and expense.

Rusted Screws and Damaged Substructures

Rusted screws and damaged substructures are other potential issues in the redecking process. The screws holding the deck boards might be rusted, making them difficult to remove without breaking. Such damage can compromise the structural integrity of the deck, adding to the complexity and cost of the redecking process.

Replacing Beams

When redecking wood decks, you might discover that beams, joists, or ledgers need replacement due to damage or rot. This requirement can result in change orders, leading to increased costs and time. While some may anticipate these costs, for many homeowners, it’s an unexpected surprise.

Why We Don’t Recommend Redecking Older Wood Decks

The biggest concern with redecking an older deck is the possibility of compromised structural integrity. Older decks may have underlying issues that aren’t immediately apparent, leading to safety concerns. Moreover, many companies cannot warranty a redecked structure due to the unknowns associated with the existing substructure.

Another drawback of redecking is that you’re essentially placing a new deck surface onto an old substructure. Despite the surface looking fresh and new, the old beams and joists may not have the strength or durability to support it long-term.

The Real Costs of Redecking Wood Decks: Is It Worth It?

While redecking might appear cost-effective initially, it may not always be the case. The potential savings can quickly be consumed by unexpected repair costs, additional labor charges, and material costs if extensive damage is uncovered during the process.

A key factor in the cost of redecking is the uncertainty of what lies beneath the surface. Until the old boards are removed, it’s impossible to fully assess the condition of the substructure. This unpredictability can lead to unexpected costs, making the process potentially more expensive than anticipated.

Making the Right Decision: Redecking vs. Building Anew

Redecking has its advantages, including potentially lower costs and less waste if the substructure is in good condition. However, the cons – unforeseen issues, potential higher costs, and lack of warranties – often outweigh these benefits.

When is it Time to Tear Down and Build A New Deck?

If your deck is significantly old or if initial inspections reveal extensive damage, it’s often safer and more cost-effective to tear it down and build anew. This approach not only ensures a structurally sound deck but also provides the opportunity for a fresh design, modern materials, and a new warranty to protect your investment. Always consult with a decking professional to guide you in making the best decision for your specific situation.

Key Takeaways

As we’ve explored in this post, redecking wood decks is a process fraught with potential challenges and hidden costs. Here are a few key takeaways to guide you in making the best decisions for your decking project.

Understanding the Risks and Making Informed Decisions

The redecking process can unveil unforeseen issues, including underlying damage, rusted screws, and compromised substructures. Always bear in mind the following:

  • Redecking is not always a straightforward or cost-saving process.
  • Always assess the condition of your deck’s substructure before deciding to redeck.
  • Unexpected costs, such as those arising from change orders, can make redecking more expensive than initially anticipated.

Prioritizing Safety, Structural Soundness, and Value for Money

When considering redecking, it’s essential to prioritize safety, structural integrity, and value for money. Consider the following points:

  • Older decks may not be suitable for redecking due to structural issues and potential warranty concerns.
  • The cost of redecking can be unpredictable due to unknown factors hidden beneath the surface of your deck.
  • At times, it can be more beneficial to tear down and build a new deck rather than redecking, ensuring a fresh design, modern materials, and a warranty.

Redecking wood decks can be a viable option under the right circumstances, but it’s important to approach the process with a clear understanding of the potential challenges and costs. Consulting with a professional can help guide your decision, ensuring the best outcome for your outdoor space.

If you need further assistance or advice regarding your deck, feel free to contact us. Our team of professionals is ready to help you make the best decisions for your decking needs.